Charlie moved to Moonlight Falls to fit in with the supernatural crowd. He meets politician Tamora Goode and falls for her. They begin dating and Charlie meets Tamora's mother Jenni Kayes and step-father Justin Kayes, brother Goodwin Goode Jr and half-brother Joe Kayes. He discovers Tamora's father Goodwin Goode Sr died years ago and comforts her as she also misses her aunt and uncle, who live all away in Twinbrook. Charlie falls deeper and deeper in love with Tamora after impressing her family, and decides to propose when Tamora saves him from zombification with her witch half-brother's cure elixir, he later moved in with Tamora and soon after proposes, and she accepts. Tamora and Charlie marry in a beach wedding, but shortly before Tamora was turned into a fairy by Joe. Charlie is elated after discovering Tamora's pregnancy. He was once kissed by Sylvia Blanestreet, but being faithful to Tamora he rejected her. Tamora soon has Dean, Tamora and Charlie's son. Tamora becomes pregnant again when Charlie and Tamora woohoo in Egypt. Charlie and Tamora have a second son, Shane, and move to Appaloosa Plains with the rest of the family. The family decides they don't like Appaloosa Plains and moves to Starlight Shores.
- Charlie originally had the Turn The Town lifetime wish until I changed it with the Change Lifetime Wish reward.