Olive moved to Oasis Springs to warn Lyla Vandermorgan (previously Lyla Grunt) that her husband and children are trying to track her down. Olive is thought to be a murderer for faking Lyla's death and keeping a fake gravestone of her in her yard. Even though Lyla's death was fake, it is unknown if she killed the other people in her yard on purpose, the signs that Olive really is a murderer are that her traits are Alluring (to lure people in to her home to kill) and Evil (self-explanatory). Olive's son Nervous briefly lived with the two women but he moved out as his trait Good conflicted with his mother's evil trait, causing disagreements. Lyla gives birth to her daughter Ariana, but as it wouldn't be safe to keep Ariana as Buzz would immediately recognise Ariana as Lyla's baby, Olive decides to move into the house across the road and care for Ariana until Lyla says its ok to see each other again. In the meantime Olive's son Nervous will look after Lyla so she isn't alone. Lyla, Olive, and Ariana are all reunited eventually, and live happily together. Eventually, due to being brought closer together, Olive and Lyla married, making Olive Ariana's step mother. Olive died of exhaustion later that day.